8.00 pm, Wednesday 4 August, 2010
The highlight of our Bach Week is this full length
performance in Trinity College
Chapel, in which members of The Parley of
Instruments compare and contrast music by
Johann Sebastian Bach and his friend and
rival Georg Philipp Telemann. Bach's
expressive penitential Cantata No. 199 Mein
Herze schwimmt im Blut is contrasted with Telemann's mock lament for a
dead canary. Telemann's great A minor suite for recorder and strings, his
chaconne for two recorders and strings, and a reconstructed oboe concerto
by Bach demonstrate the inventive ways in which both composers wrote for
Baroque woodwind instruments.
PROGRAMME
Telemann: Suite in A minor, TWV 55:a2
J S Bach: Cantata Mein Herze schwimmt im Blut, BWV 199
-- Interval --
J S Bach: Concerto in F major, BWV 1053a
Telemann: Chaconne in F minor, TWV 55:f1/8
Telemann: Cantata O weh, mein Canarin ist tot, TWV 20:37
PERFORMERS
Philippa Hyde soprano
Philip Thorby recorder
Gail Hennessy oboe and recorder
Judy Tarling, Henrietta Wayne violin
Jane Rogers viola
Mark Caudle violoncello
Peter Holman harpsichord
This concert was well worth attending just for the beautiful playing of Gail
Hennessy, which had a suppleness and a variety and quality of tone,
particularly on the oboe (Gail also played recorder this evening). Add to
that the mastery of Philip Thorby, with his typically exuberant sense of
dress, and the consummate ensemble for which The Parley of Instruments is
renowned, and it already amounted to a glorious concert in purely
instrumental terms.
We also had the singing of Philippa Hyde in an unusual cantata each by J. S.
Bach and Telemann, and, although it sometimes seemed that the balance of her
voice against the accompaniment was not quite as clear it might have been
(and which may have resulted from her standing generously not as far forward
from the other musicians as she might), she gave fine performances in both:
what linked them was a theme concentrated on death, and, whereas the Bach
piece was the graphic embodiment of a pious soul's hopes for salvation, the
Telemann's tragicomic tone perfectly ran the gamut of emotions from
desolation to anger, and from hectoring to eulogy on a topic in which one
might have been surprised to find such passion.
In summary, a thoroughly enjoyable evening's music!
-- Anthony Davis, 16 Aug 10